Shadiest Midtown streets for a summer walk
On a July day the sidewalks of 51st Street, 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue are in shade 92% of the time from 8 AM to 8 PM, the most of the 38 Midtown streets and avenues below. The wide ones get the most sun: 9th Avenue, 34th Street to 59th Street (78%), and among cross streets 34th Street (79%) and East 34th Street (80%). Which side you walk on matters more than which street.
Which side to walk on
Cross streets
- 8 to 11 AM: the north side of the street (99% in shade, against 74% on the other side)
- 11 AM to 2 PM: the south side of the street (93% in shade, against 44% on the other side)
- 1 to 5 PM: the south side of the street (100% in shade, against 80% on the other side)
- 3 to 7 PM: the south side of the street (100% in shade, against 92% on the other side)
Avenues
- 8 to 11 AM: the east side of the avenue (100% in shade, against 90% on the other side)
- 11 AM to 2 PM: the east side of the avenue (90% in shade, against 43% on the other side)
- 1 to 5 PM: the west side of the avenue (80% in shade, against 66% on the other side)
- 3 to 7 PM: the west side of the avenue (100% in shade, against 88% on the other side)
Averages over the streets below on July 15. Manhattan's grid is tilted about 29° from true north; "north side" and "west side" mean the grid's, the way New Yorkers say it.
Cross streets
| # | Street | Shade, 8 AM to 8 PM | Shadier side, 8 to 11 AM | Shadier side, 11 AM to 2 PM | Shadier side, 1 to 5 PM | Shadier side, 3 to 7 PM |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 51st Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 92% | North side, 100% | South side, 94% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 2 | 53rd Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 91% | North side, 99% | South side, 94% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 3 | 52nd Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 90% | North side, 100% | South side, 94% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 4 | 54th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 90% | North side, 99% | South side, 94% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 5 | 58th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 90% | North side, 99% | South side, 95% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 6 | 41st Street 6th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 89% | North side, 100% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 7 | 43rd Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 89% | North side, 100% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 8 | 49th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 89% | North side, 97% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 9 | 50th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 89% | North side, 99% | South side, 89% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 10 | 39th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 88% | North side, 100% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 11 | 48th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 88% | North side, 99% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 12 | 56th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 88% | North side, 99% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 13 | 55th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 87% | North side, 100% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 14 | East 57th Street 3rd Avenue to 5th Avenue | 87% | North side, 99% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 15 | 35th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 86% | North side, 99% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 16 | 38th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 86% | North side, 99% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 17 | 40th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 86% | North side, 99% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 18 | 44th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 86% | North side, 99% | South side, 93% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 19 | East 42nd Street 3rd Avenue to 5th Avenue | 86% | North side, 100% | South side, 94% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 20 | 37th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 85% | North side, 99% | South side, 91% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 21 | 45th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 85% | North side, 99% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 22 | 47th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 85% | North side, 99% | South side, 91% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 23 | 36th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 83% | North side, 99% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 24 | 57th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 82% | North side, 100% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 25 | 42nd Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 81% | North side, 100% | South side, 94% | South side, 99% | South side, 99% |
| 26 | 46th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 80% | North side, 98% | South side, 89% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
| 27 | East 34th Street 3rd Avenue to 5th Avenue | 80% | North side, 99% | South side, 93% | South side, 99% | South side, 100% |
| 28 | 34th Street 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue | 79% | North side, 98% | South side, 92% | South side, 100% | South side, 100% |
Avenues
| # | Street | Shade, 8 AM to 8 PM | Shadier side, 8 to 11 AM | Shadier side, 11 AM to 2 PM | Shadier side, 1 to 5 PM | Shadier side, 3 to 7 PM |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Madison Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 90% | East side, 100% | East side, 92% | West side, 81% | West side, 100% |
| 2 | Lexington Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 89% | East side, 100% | East side, 93% | West side, 79% | West side, 100% |
| 3 | 3rd Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 88% | East side, 100% | East side, 92% | West side, 81% | West side, 100% |
| 4 | Broadway 34th Street to 59th Street | 87% | East side, 100% | East side, 80% | West side, 87% | West side, 100% |
| 5 | 5th Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 86% | East side, 100% | East side, 90% | West side, 79% | West side, 100% |
| 6 | 7th Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 86% | East side, 100% | East side, 90% | West side, 79% | West side, 100% |
| 7 | Park Avenue 46th Street to 59th Street | 85% | East side, 100% | East side, 92% | West side, 80% | West side, 100% |
| 8 | 6th Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 84% | East side, 100% | East side, 90% | West side, 81% | West side, 100% |
| 9 | 8th Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 82% | East side, 100% | East side, 89% | West side, 77% | West side, 100% |
| 10 | 9th Avenue 34th Street to 59th Street | 78% | East side, 100% | East side, 91% | West side, 80% | West side, 99% |
Questions
Which side of the street is shady in Midtown in the summer?
On cross streets, the south side in the afternoon (100% in shade from 1 to 5 PM on a July day, on average) and the north side in the morning. On avenues, the east side in the morning and the west side in the afternoon.
What is the shadiest street in Midtown?
Of the 38 Midtown streets and avenues Suncatcher has worked out, 51st Street, 5th Avenue to 8th Avenue is the shadiest on a July day: its sidewalks are in shade 92% of the time from 8 AM to 8 PM. 9th Avenue, 34th Street to 59th Street is the sunniest, at 78%.
Do trees shade Midtown sidewalks?
Hardly. Almost all of Midtown's sidewalk shade comes from buildings: with the trees taken out, no street here gets more than 24 points sunnier on a July afternoon.
How this is worked out
Points every 8 meters along each sidewalk, at the foot of the buildings, mid-block (crossings left out), each traced through July 15 with the same shadow engine as the map: every building's footprint and height and every street tree. Shade is the share of sidewalk out of direct sun over the hours shown. Frontage on parks and plazas (Bryant Park, Times Square, Herald Square) has no building line and is left out. Scaffolding, sidewalk sheds and awnings aren't in the data and add shade of their own.